Horror movies come in all shapes and forms, but some hidden gems never get the attention they deserve. If you’re tired of mainstream horror and want something unique, terrifying, and underrated, this list of the top 10 underrated horror movies on Amazon Prime will give you nightmares in the best way possible.
Best Underrated Horror Movies on Amazon Prime
| Movie | Year | Key Themes | IMDb Rating | Director | Main Actors |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Autopsy of Jane Doe | 2016 | Supernatural Horror, Mystery | 6.8/10 | André Øvredal | Emile Hirsch, Brian Cox |
| Lake Mungo | 2008 | Psychological Horror, Found Footage | 6.3/10 | Joel Anderson | Rosie Traynor, David Pledger |
| Session 9 | 2001 | Psychological Horror, Haunted Places | 6.4/10 | Brad Anderson | David Caruso, Peter Mullan |
| The Blackcoat’s Daughter | 2015 | Supernatural Horror, Occult | 5.9/10 | Oz Perkins | Emma Roberts, Kiernan Shipka |
| The Dark and the Wicked | 2020 | Psychological Horror, Demonic Possession | 6.1/10 | Bryan Bertino | Marin Ireland, Michael Abbott Jr. |
| We Are Still Here | 2015 | Haunted House, Gore Horror | 5.7/10 | Ted Geoghegan | Barbara Crampton, Andrew Sensenig |
| The Wailing | 2016 | Supernatural Horror, Mystery | 7.4/10 | Na Hong-jin | Kwak Do-won, Hwang Jung-min |
| Terrified (Aterrados) | 2017 | Paranormal Horror, Argentinian Horror | 6.5/10 | Demián Rugna | Maximiliano Ghione, Norberto Gonzalo |
| The House of the Devil | 2009 | Satanic Horror, Slow-Burn Suspense | 6.3/10 | Ti West | Jocelin Donahue, Tom Noonan |
| The Canal | 2014 | Psychological Horror, Supernatural Mystery | 5.9/10 | Ivan Kavanagh | Rupert Evans, Antonia Campbell-Hughes |
1. The Autopsy of Jane Doe (2016)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A gripping and unpredictable supernatural horror that takes place in a morgue.
- Acting & Performance: Emile Hirsch and Brian Cox deliver fantastic performances.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Claustrophobic, eerie, and full of chilling visuals.
- Themes & Impact: A unique mystery-driven horror with a truly terrifying premise.
Why Watch?
- A slow-building horror with an unforgettable mystery.
- Jumpscares and atmospheric dread make it one of the creepiest horror films.
- Perfect mix of supernatural and psychological horror.
2. Lake Mungo (2008)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A found-footage horror movie that feels unnervingly real.
- Acting & Performance: Convincing performances that make it feel like a real documentary.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Subtle, creepy, and slow-burning horror.
- Themes & Impact: Explores grief, loss, and the supernatural in a deeply unsettling way.
Why Watch?
- One of the scariest mockumentary horror films ever made.
- No cheap jump scares—just pure psychological horror.
- An emotional, eerie experience that sticks with you.
3. Session 9 (2001)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A psychological horror set in an abandoned mental asylum.
- Acting & Performance: Intense performances that build deep unease.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Dark, decaying settings that create pure dread.
- Themes & Impact: Explores paranoia, insanity, and the unknown.
Why Watch?
- One of the best slow-burn horror films ever made.
- Tense, unsettling, and genuinely disturbing.
- A horror experience that stays with you long after the credits roll.
4. The Blackcoat’s Daughter (2015)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A chilling, slow-burn supernatural horror with psychological elements.
- Acting & Performance: Emma Roberts and Kiernan Shipka deliver eerie, haunting performances.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Dark, cold, and unsettling visuals enhance the horror.
- Themes & Impact: Explores themes of loneliness, demonic possession, and existential dread.
Why Watch?
- Atmospheric horror that creeps under your skin.
- A unique take on supernatural horror with deep psychological elements.
- A slow-burning thriller that rewards patient viewers.
5. The Dark and the Wicked (2020)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A deeply disturbing film about supernatural evil consuming a family.
- Acting & Performance: Marin Ireland delivers an intense, emotional performance.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Oppressive and terrifying visuals that intensify dread.
- Themes & Impact: Examines grief, paranoia, and demonic horror in a brutally effective way.
Why Watch?
- One of the scariest indie horror films in recent years.
- A relentless, nihilistic horror experience.
- Perfect for fans of supernatural dread.
6. We Are Still Here (2015)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A haunted house horror with a unique blend of atmospheric horror and gore.
- Acting & Performance: Barbara Crampton delivers a strong lead performance.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Snow-covered landscapes add a chilling effect to the story.
- Themes & Impact: Explores guilt, revenge, and classic haunted house tropes with a fresh take.
Why Watch?
- A perfect mix of atmospheric horror and brutal scares.
- Retro horror fans will love its throwback style.
- Unexpectedly gory and intense.
7. The Wailing (2016)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A masterful blend of supernatural horror, crime thriller, and folklore.
- Acting & Performance: A powerful ensemble cast delivers deep emotional performances.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Cinematic brilliance that immerses viewers in its eerie world.
- Themes & Impact: Explores paranoia, spiritual warfare, and the nature of evil.
Why Watch?
- One of the best international horror films ever made.
- A slow-burn mystery with shocking twists.
- Unpredictable, disturbing, and unforgettable.
8. Terrified (Aterrados) (2017)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A terrifying Argentinian horror film filled with shocking supernatural encounters.
- Acting & Performance: Engaging performances enhance the fear factor.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Genuinely scary visuals and nightmarish sequences.
- Themes & Impact: Explores the unseen terrors lurking in everyday life.
Why Watch?
- One of the scariest Latin American horror films ever made.
- A must-watch for supernatural horror fans.
- Delivers relentless, nightmarish scares.
9. The House of the Devil (2009)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A slow-burning satanic horror film that builds dread expertly.
- Acting & Performance: Jocelin Donahue delivers a stellar lead performance.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: A perfect recreation of 1980s horror aesthetics.
- Themes & Impact: Plays with classic horror tropes while delivering a fresh take.
Why Watch?
- A must-see for fans of retro horror.
- Slow-burn tension that pays off in an unforgettable climax.
- A love letter to classic horror.
10. The Canal (2014)
Review:
- Plot & Suspense: A psychological horror about a film archivist uncovering disturbing secrets.
- Acting & Performance: Rupert Evans delivers a compelling, unsettling performance.
- Cinematography & Atmosphere: Dark and eerie cinematography adds to the horror.
- Themes & Impact: Explores themes of grief, madness, and the supernatural.
Why Watch?
- A hidden gem that deserves more recognition.
- Creepy, atmospheric, and full of dread.
- A unique take on psychological and supernatural horror.
Our Top Picks & Recommendations
- Best for Paranormal Horror: The Wailing (2016) – A Korean horror masterpiece blending mystery, exorcism, and supernatural horror.
- Best for Found Footage Horror: Lake Mungo (2008) – A haunting psychological horror that feels real.
- Best for Psychological Horror: Session 9 (2001) – A terrifying descent into madness in an abandoned asylum.
- Best for Slow-Burn Suspense: The House of the Devil (2009) – A retro-inspired satanic horror that rewards patience.
If you’re tired of generic horror films, these underrated horror gems on Amazon Prime will leave you terrified, unsettled, and wanting more! 🎃🔪👻